The New York Times: Clueless in Jerusalem
Papers like the New York Times, which propogate the Palestinian Authority's false narrative to Western audiences, only prolong the Palestinian people's suffering at the hands of their failed leaders
Across the West Bank, dozens of schools, youth camps, sports festivals, and town squares are named after mass murderers of Jews. Effusive praise of these terrorists regularly flows on PA government TV, and in speeches by PA leaders. The PA also spends millions – supplied partly by U.S. aid – as pensions for convicted Palestinian terrorists in Israeli jails.
Repeating the slanders of the Holocaust, PA TV and newspapers regularly castigate Jews as “monkeys and pigs,” “a germ among us,” and a “parasitic worm.” The PA also spreads incendiary allegations such as false claims that Israel poisons Palestinian wells, infects Palestinian men with the AIDs virus, and kidnaps Palestinians to sell their organs.
Unlike Israel, where schools teach tolerance and respect for Arab and Islamic culture, PA TV programs also urge children to become suicide bombers, and demand the extermination of the Jews. Phrases like “they must be butchered and must be killed,” “kill them to the last one,” and “their children will be exterminated” are common fare.
Mr. Abbas’s eliminationist agenda is also manifest in his rigid insistence on a broad “right of return” for descendants of the 600,000 Palestinians who fled the new Israeli state in 1947-48.
Mr. Abbas insists that these now-millions of people have a right to settle not only in a Palestinian state, but also in Israel. This would end Israel’s Jewish majority, and turn Israel into a province of the Palestinian state.
On these facts, how could anyone describe the PA as ready for a lasting peace with Israel?
Second, consider Mr. Thrall’s claim that Israel, by stubbornly holding onto the West Bank, squandered a chance for a two-state peace. In fact, it is Israel that has repeatedly offered a Palestinian state, and the Palestinians who have always said no.
In 1947 the U.N. voted for two states in Palestine – one for Jews, one for Arabs. Israel said yes and invited its Arab residents to stay with equal civil rights assured. But the Palestinian Arabs said no and launched a war to destroy Israel.
This Palestinian “no” has never changed, despite Israel’s 1967 land-for-peace offer (rejected), the 1993 Oslo accords (sabotaged by Palestinian terrorism), and Israel’s three statehood offers in 2000, 2001, and 2008 (all rejected).
The last three statehood offers included all of Gaza, at least 97 percent of a contiguous West Bank, compensating land swaps, and a capital in Jerusalem. The Saudi diplomat Prince Bandar, who participated in the 2000 Camp David negotiations, called the PA’s refusal to accept that statehood offer "a crime against Palestinians.”
On these facts, how can anyone place primary blame on Israel – and not Palestinian leaders – for the lack of a Palestinian state?
Finally, consider Mr. Thrall’s claim that Israel is the cause of the Palestinians’ rage. The PA – not Israel – is responsible for refusing all offers of a lasting two-state peace; for failing to resettle Palestinian “refugees” in permanent homes; for failing to create a non-corrupt national government; and most important, for constantly brainwashing its people to emulate terrorists, hate Jews, and blame Israel for the PA’s many failures.
Contra Mr. Thrall, the PA is both the instigator and the beneficiary of the West Bank Palestinians’ rage. By steering such rage against Israel through its propaganda apparatus, the PA deflects resentment for its own miserable performance, and keeps alive its aspiration to destroy Israel.
Writers like Mr. Thrall, and papers like the New York Times, which propagate the PA’s false narrative to Western audiences, serve as the unwitting tools of this deception.
Such writers may believe they help the Palestinians by deflecting attention from their leaders’ many failings. But by providing cover for the PA’s dead-end politics of hatred and scapegoating, they only prolong the Palestinian people’s suffering at the hands of their failed leaders.
Henry Kopel is an attorney with the U.S. Department of Justice in Connecticut. The views here are his own, and do not reflect the views of the Justice Department
Read more on: new york times, New York Times and Israel, New York Times and Palestinian Authority, Henry Kopel, Henry Kopel Palestinian Authority, Hamas, palestinian authority, The Third Intifada, Nathan Thrall, Jerusalem, Benjamin Netanyahu, Palestinian incitement, PATV, Mahmoud Abbas, Oslo Accords, 1967 borders, New York Times bias, Camp David, and the commentator
- NY Democrat pleads with Republican not to share document proposing confiscation of guns
- Sunday Times blood libel cartoon, on Holocaust Memorial Day no less
- Oregon woman raped after police refuse to send out response unit
- Palestinian jailed for Facebook like
- 'Muslim Patrol' vigilantes attempt to control London streets
We are wholly dependent on the kindness of our readers for our continued work. We thank you in advance for any support you can offer.