Let’s make fun of Germany and France… But then learn from their mistakes

What do German hand wringing over bin Laden's death and French economic woes have in common? They speak to civilisational decline.

20c5a52384e08fb9ad80ff30bd3c41e0513c2ede
28afeec47808a46741242eeecfe39bbc94ff3741
Daniel J. Mitchell
On 8 May 2011 09:53

We have two completely unrelated topics from Germany and France, but both fit in the broader theme of Europe’s gradual, self-inflicted suicide.

Let’s start with the Germans. I’m not a big fan of the country’s Chancellor, Angela Merkel. She is supposedly a conservative, but she certainly hasn’t done much to reduce the burden of government. But I give her credit for making the rational and moral observation that, “I’m glad that killing bin Laden was successful.”

Based on the reaction, however, you would think she had come out in favor of torturing puppies. Here are some excerpts from a story on a German news site.

"Katrin Göring-Eckardt, Green party MP, Bundestag vice president and leading member of the Evangelical Church of Germany, told the Berliner Zeitung she was glad bin Laden was no longer leading a terrorist group. “But you can’t be happy about his death,” she said. On Monday, Merkel told reporters that bin Laden’s death at the hands of US forces was “good news.” “I’m glad that killing bin Laden was successful,” she said. The criticism of Merkel’s comments came not only from political opposition, but from her own party, echoing discomfort expressed by some observers at the emotional, celebratory reaction of many Americans and foreign politicians around the world after bin Laden’s killing. Siegfried Kauder, a member of Merkel’s conservative Christian Democratic Union (CDU), slammed her remarks, calling them reminiscent of something a person would say in the “middle ages.”

I’m not an expert on Germany’s political system and I’m certainly not a close observer of the nation’s various political figures, so I have no idea if these critics really believe the things they said. But does that really matter? It’s a bad sign if you have a nation where the political elite actually feel sadness that a monster is dead. And it’s a bad sign if you have a nation where the political elite think they should act like it’s unfortunate that a monster is dead.

Let’s now shift to the French. There’s been a lot of attention paid to bailouts of Greece, Ireland, and Portugal, which certainly is appropriate since all of us should be outraged that we are paying (via the IMF) to reward profligate politicians and special-interest groups.

Unfortunately, there are more nations in fiscal trouble, which probably means even more bailouts. Most people think Spain, Italy, and Belgium are next in line, but France is a dark-horse contender in the race to fiscal crisis. Read some of what Matthew Lynn wrote in his Bloomberg column.

"It is increasingly politically unstable, its debt position is getting worse all the time, it is losing competitiveness against Germany, and it shows little willingness to change. Those are all good reasons for the bond markets to make France the next battleground. …France’s debt position is getting worse all the time. In 2010, the nation ran the fifth-biggest budget deficit in the euro area, at 7 percent of GDP. It was beaten only by Greece, Portugal, Ireland and Spain — hardly great company. Its stock of outstanding government debt hit 81 percent of GDP in 2010. That figure will reach 90 percent this year and 95 percent in 2012, according to London-based consulting firm Capital Economics. Italy has more outstanding debt — 119 percent of GDP in 2010 — but it isn’t adding to the pile the same way France is. What the markets really look at is the direction you are traveling in — and in the case of France, it isn’t good. …Sarkozy came to power promising to shake up the economy. He delivered little. …it is hard to believe that the euro crisis will end with the bailout of Portugal. Other countries are going to get caught in the crossfire. When you look around for the next candidate, France has what it takes to be the next blowup."

I still think Spain goes bust first, but Lynn makes a compelling case. Bad things are bound to happen when politicians expand the burden of government, increase tax burdens, and expand dependency. And that’s been the pattern in France, regardless of who’s in charge.

Notwithstanding my snarky title, the purpose of this post is not mock the Germans and the French. I’m certainly not averse to some good-natured ribbing of foreigners, but there’s a serious point to be made. Moral relativism and big government are signs of societal decay, and my real concern is that America is slowly heading down the same path as Western Europe.

Let’s learn from Germany and France and avoid making the same mistakes. ...

Daniel J. Mitchell is a Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute, the free-market, Washington D.C. think tank. His articles are cross-posted on his blog, by agreement.

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus

We are wholly dependent on the kindness of our readers for our continued work. We thank you in advance for any support you can offer.

 
Options
Advertisement
Recommended
Advertisement
Advertisement