A cynical view of Middle East democracy -- One person, one vote, one time?
The latest rampages following the "Innocence of Muslims" film do not augur well for the future of MidEast democracy
The US ambassador is killed in Benghazi over a 13 minute film trailer; protests in Cairo; Copts increasingly persecuted; Christians in Gaza allegedly facing forced conversion to Islam...
We could add to the list from around the Middle East in those countries supposedly released from dictatorial oppression into a new democratic "spring" of freedom and power to the people.
Forgive my cynicism, but that's not what I'm seeing. I'm seeing millions of ordinary people who seized the moment to get rid of ruthless (psychotic?) despots in the hope of gaining a voice in the running of their lives and their country's life. Sadly, we are now also seeing extremist Islamists taking over the reins of oppression all over the Middle East; and it's not over yet by a long way.
Islamist groups, be they Salafis, Al Qaeda or the Muslim Brotherhood, have shown themselves effective in influencing populations that are in turmoil. They promise order, justice, democracy, lower taxes, whatever it takes to swing an eventual democratic vote in their favour.
The supreme example of this is in Egypt, where the Muslim Brotherhood were the best organised and most prepared of all political groups to take advantage of the dramatic changes that ousted President Mubarak. Let's face it, after decades of political drought they were the only political group still left; and that is only because they knew how to keep their heads down and bide their time.
As the dominoes of revolution knocked each other over from Tunisia eastwards, down to Yemen and up to Syria, the Brotherhood and Salafists must have thought that all their Christmases (sorry, all their Eids) had come at once as they stepped into political vacuums one after another to sway the people towards Sharia.
Oily words were spoken and promises of moderation made with crossed fingers to the democracy-encouraging West, as the Islamists prepared the ground for their own form of democracy; one vote for each person; Muslim, Christian, whoever... but you only ever get one – ever.
Am I being overly cynical? Tell me after we see what action Libya takes against the murderers of the US ambassador and after we see how hard President Mursi cracks down on the demonstrators, feverish over a 13 minute film trailer. And finally, tell me when we see if either regime (or any of the others) allows any significant political opponents to arise who could defeat them in future democratic elections – if they ever take place.
How long did democracy last in Gaza before political opponents were tortured and thrown off buildings? How many opposition parties are there in the West Bank – outside prison, that is? Yup - one person, one vote, and only one time.
Nick Gray blogs at cmewonline.com and Tweets at @cmew2
Read more on: Nick Gray, US Ambassador to Libya killed by protesters, Benghazi, protests in Egypt over Innocence of Muslims, Innocence of Muslims, Salafism, al qaeda, muslim brotherhood, Muslim brotherhood in Egypt, Mubarak, Syria, democracy in Gaza, and President Mursi
- NY Democrat pleads with Republican not to share document proposing confiscation of guns
- Sunday Times blood libel cartoon, on Holocaust Memorial Day no less
- Palestinian jailed for Facebook like
- 'Muslim Patrol' vigilantes attempt to control London streets
- Saudi cleric who raped and killed daughter receives small fine
We are wholly dependent on the kindness of our readers for our continued work. We thank you in advance for any support you can offer.