May 17, 2012
MUST READ
ARTICLE

PM David Cameron's speech didn't cut it for true Tories

Prime Minister David Cameron’s blue-sky conference speech left the party faithful full of doubts, writes our UK Political Editor Harry Cole in Manchester

David Cameron takes to the stage at Manchester Central
David Cameron takes to the stage at Manchester Central
Harry Cole, UK Political Editor

By Harry Cole

on 5 October 2011 at 3pm

total rating of 4.11

Sponsored Message: Argentina

Brit Rock and soulers Florence and the Machine have had a good party conference season. Not only did Ed Miliband use their cover of “You’ve got the Love” to close his speech last week but the Prime Minister used their hit, “The Dog Days are Over” in his introductory video before his closing speech to the Conservative Party Conference in Manchester.

Except the dog days are not over are they Dave?

The dog days have barely begun.

Spending in real terms is up. Borrowing will Increase by a shocking 52 percent in this parliament. Markets are down, as is the nation’s morale.

It was a nice try, but Cameron is delusional if he thinks the blue sky that made up his stage backdrop is anywhere near to reality.

Cameron’s speech was not just to the party faithful, though he did butter them up at the off, praising them as “not just winners but doers”. It seems there has been some collective amnesia about not actually winning the election.

A hard line was taken for the room we all sat in on the cuts and Labour’s legacy, and the crowd loved it. The biggest claps were for a line the Prime Minister borrowed from his Liberal Democrat deputy Nick Clegg in regard to Labour: “We must never let them anywhere near our economy ever again” Cue eruption number one.

The second crowd pleaser was a direct hit down the barrel of the camera to Ed Miliband who courted controversy at his own conference by pausing after his line: “I am not Tony Blair” to allow the Labour crowd to boo their most successful ever leader.

Cameron plunged the knife in with: “We don’t boo our previous leaders,” and the crowd happily twisted the knife with a rapturous and sustained round of applause.

With the party buttered up, Cameron turned his attention to the cameras in the ambitious hope that the country was watching. And this is where the speech got a little schizophrenic.

It was time to: “Turn the ship around”. Britain’s best days are not over, but there was no real acknowledgement of the dire, dark days still to come. No reference to the fact it’s going to get worse before it gets better.

He didn’t say, “let sunshine win the day”, but so desperate was the Prime Minister to push an optimistic message that he might have gone the whole hog and told us all to join hands.

It’s all very well telling people that prices will rise and there will job losses, but people already know that they are scared without having to be told they are.

Suddenly, we saw the return of the erstwhile “One Nation” David Cameron. Having played the fiscal Thatcherite to please the room and fix the roof, Harold “One Nation” Macmillan was being name checked, and the love for the (failed, socialist) NHS was being professed as an item of passionate, eternal love.

This section of the speech was quite clearly written by another member of the team: the style and content was noticeably different and led to a confused and somewhat jumbled message. In trying to play to the centre at the same time as buttering up all strands of the party the Prime Minister ended up sounding confused and muddled.

Is he a cutter and fiscal wizard, or is he a "One Nationer"? Is the deficit the most important issue or is it the NHS, children, families, gay marriage and workers’ rights? We were meant to buy the fact that all of these are at the heart of what this government is doing.

It’s important to note that the “Big Society” message was ditched. Instead, the talk was of a “bigger better society” with the smack of firm government and strong leadership -- the theme that the leadership was attempting to push throughout the conference.

There was nothing new said. And having started well, it ended in a blur of centrist fudge with no clear and distinct message behind it. It was “steady as we go” from the Prime Minister, but the destination was snoredom for those who were hoping for original ideas on a truly Conservative future for Great Britain.

Harry Cole is the UK Political Editor for The Commentator. He tweets at @MrHarryColeand is the News Editor for the Guido Fawkes blog

Print
COMMENTS (12)
West Midlands Activist says:
05 October 2011

How can you say "PM David Cameron's speech didn't cut it for true Tories" at the same time as saying "...and the crowd love LD it"?

James Scott says:
05 October 2011

Harry, I think your summary is schizophrenic, not DC's speech... I quote: "It was a nice try, but Cameron is delusional if he thinks the blue sky that made up his stage backdrop is anywhere near to reality" ... and "It’s all very well telling people that prices will rise and there will job losses, but people already know that they are scared without having to be told they are." Which is your actual view? Also - I think you should give David credit for treating the electorate like grown ups. Yes, they do now it is going to rough and they are scared, but it doesn't do any harm to send out positive messages either. You can be a cutter (we have to be, or the AAA rating will go) AND be liberal-minded with the money that is left. I see no contradiction in that.

Mal says:
05 October 2011

I think that Cameron has to strike a balance between austerity measures, which will cost people their jobs, and re-balancing the economy by switching more projects from the public sector to the private sector. I would strongly advise him to wait until that transition has taken place, before taking on the unions. If he does wait, and there is a transiton of jobs from public to private sector, he may well be able to achieve a re-balancing with minimal disruption. Cameron are the Coalition are trying to do the right things with their economic strategy and the UK is in a by far bettter place than the Eurozone. I also like the 'common sense' approach to European legislation. The Uk should not have to put up with petty regulation from the EU, and it's about time that the Human Rights of the victim were put before that of the criminal!

Dave B says:
06 October 2011

My impression was that it was a very corporatist speech. The hi-speed rail boon-doggle is still on, and the changes to planning permission law now appears to be to enable retail parks.

He tried to explain the British national interest in the Libya adventure, I was left with the impression he doesn't know how we ended at war there either.

Herbert says:
06 October 2011

We can all hear the clock ticking. Cameron came across as a man trying to push the plugs into his party's ears. It might work with his followers but it won't work with the rest of us.

Sir Trev Skint says:
06 October 2011

With the BBC, ITV, Channel4 and Skynews constantly talking about cuts, austerity, hard times, riots, debt, job losses and every thing else they can negativise to break up the coalition, I think it's damned amazing that we still have growth in the economy and that half the population have set fire to themselves in the street.

The press need their heads smacking together and told to man-up and stop doing down Great Britain!!!

Barry Sheridan says:
06 October 2011

Speeches are all well and good, but it is action that counts. What is required are efforts to allow the private sector to grow. That means rolling back some of the tier upon tier of regulation and taxation heaped on business by government, which in this case mostly means the blind adoption of endless EU edicts. The likelihood of this government doing that in any meaningful way is not great.

Herbert says:
06 October 2011

Sir Trev Skint Says: 'The press need their heads smacking together and told to man-up and stop doing down Great Britain!!!'

Oh I see, lie you mean? Pretend it isn't happening/ Something like the Stalinist tractor production figures, would that suit you?

The Libertarian says:
06 October 2011

The world is now devoid of true leadership. Cameron sold his soul to the liberal democrats to become prime minister. Most of the time it appears to me that the liberal democrats are running the country. If I was a UK voter I would not bother to go to the polls to vote for any of them. Same here in the US, I will only go to the polls to vote obama out of office, not because I like any of the alternative contenders What a sad reflection on world politicians when we are always voting for the least destructive alternative

Screwtape says:
06 October 2011

I stand to be corrected, but, amazingly, I don't believe the words "climate change" presented themselves. As for Lady Macbeth's excitement at the Gay Marriage announcement, perhaps Boles or one of the others has promised her that she can be bridesmaid.

Donna Edmunds says:
06 October 2011

I think the title of this peice is a bit presumtuous, to say the least. There is a lot of debate within the party as to what policies we should be pursuing on all sorts of issues. I've spent much of the last few days at conference having discussions with all sorts of people: MPs, Councillors, party faithful and non-members alike. There was hardly a consensus view on almost any subject. So no matter which policies he backed, SOMEONE who considers themselves a 'true Tory' would have been disappointed. I think he struck the right note, therefore, by focussing instead on an optimistic message. He was essentially back to the 'Big Society' idea in all but name. But let's face it, there ARE hard times ahead, and the party has spent the last 18 months making this case. People ARE going to have to work harder for less if we want to recover as a country, in the shorter term at the very least. How best to get them to do this? To talk even more about doom and gloom, or to assure them that we, as a nation, are capable of stepping up to the plate and overcoming the problems that face us? Neither Ed Milliband nor Nick Clegg were able to deliver a speech anywhere near as optimistic or inspiring. It was Cameron doing what he does best. I'm starting to deeply suspect that you just like criticising him, no matter what he does Harry.

James Russell Stoneham says:
10 October 2011

Very well written. I heartily agree with this article.

Add Comment
MOST POPULAR
TOP COMMENTS
ADVERTISEMENT
RECEIVE UPDATES

Sign up to receive updates from

The Commentator website!

RELATED ARTICLES
OUR SUPPORTERS
FIND US ON FACEBOOK
ADVERTISEMENT