Tunisia: How UK's "not Islam" narrative helps terrorists

UPDATE (for which see below article on Britain's new pro-terror narrative, dated July 1, 2015): Islam can be a religion of peace, but it can also be a religion of war, and many shades in between, including terror. The disastrous narrative that it's not Islam, pushed by British PM Cameron after the Tunisia massacre is a massive boost to the terrorists. It's vital that Cameron et al understand their terrible error

Tunisia_massacre
Is this is Islam?
The_commentator_logo_updated9
the commentator
On 28 June 2015 13:37

We're going to keep this simple and short, because the message just doesn't seem to get through. And (see below for full update), Britain it now appears has fallen in line with the terrorist narrative. Here's why:

In the wake of the horrific massacre by an Islamic terrorist of (mainly British) holiday-makers on a beach in Tunisia, UK Prime Minister David Cameron came out with a line we have heard from him, Barack Obama, France's Francois Hollande, Australia's Tony Abbott, and so many others in the wake of Islamist mass murder.

This is what Cameron said just after news of the massacre broke: "This is not in the name of Islam; it’s a perverted ideology and we must fight it,".

We have made the point many times about Mr. Cameron's qualifications to speak about Islamic theology -- he doesn't have any. In any case, it's idiotic to say it's not in "the name" of Islam, because the people who do such things are quite explicit that they are doing it precisely in "the name" of Islam.

So let's just say that he means well, and that he's pushing the "virtuous lie". Get your Plato out.

But before you do, consider this: what are wavering radical Islamists in Britain and other Western countries going to do with such a statement?

Here's a though experiment. Imagine you are one of those waverers. You hear the British prime minister saying that slaughtering people is not Islamic. You have read quite a bit of the Koran, so you know that there are both peaceful and violent injunctions within it.

As someone who already has radical tendencies, you go to your radical Imam. "What's all this about, then"? "David Cameron says this is against Islam?"

Stay with the thought experiment. The Imam, with a knowing smile, says: "Don't take my word for it, see this verse, and this one, and that one, and this one, and that one over there. They all allow for Muslims to kill Infidels, en masse, if necessary. So, my boy, do you trust David Cameron's words, or the words of the Prophet in the Holy Koran?"

If you doubt that such verses exist -- and indeed have profound significance in the Koran and other Islamic teachings -- see the writings of our contributor Raymond Ibrahim, a native speaker of Arabic and top scholar on such matters.

Now, back to the thought experiment: what is going to be the net result of Western leaders' insistance that, "this is not Islam"?

The following: The young, potential radical now totally distrusts the Western political establishment, which has simply lied about the situation. Simultaneously, the radical Imam seems even more impressive than he did before: he knows the truth, and he can prove it.

Our leaders in the West are right not to pander to hatred of Muslims. But in denying the hard fact that mass terror can indeed be justified according to Islamic texts, they are making terrorism more likely, not less. Just capture the facts, and apply logic. Or is that too much to ask?

UPDATE: Yes it is. On July 1, 2015 Prime Minister Cameron went so far as to say that we should not call Islamic State, "Islamic" State. He even applauded the BBC for following the extreme Left narrative on that score. On one level it is so cretinous that one almost thinks about giving up. It's like saying every Pope until Vatican II wasn't a Catholic. On another level, as the above article shows, darkness descends: Cameron, unwittingly -- he must have morons as advisors; and that's his best excuse -- is providing a massive boost to the terrorist narrative. Expect more terrorism in Britain after this.

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus

We are wholly dependent on the kindness of our readers for our continued work. We thank you in advance for any support you can offer.

 
Options
Advertisement
Recommended
Advertisement
Advertisement